Forums for the Business Analyst

 
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Data Analysis f...  The Kobayashi Maru Data Project
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 7/2/2017 1:45 PM
User is offline deadduck
1 posts
No Ranking


The Kobayashi Maru Data Project 

Hi,

I have a scenario, this actually happened to me, and It can't be completely uncommon, although the overall problem is, probably, pretty extreme.  Anyways, the scenario,

You arrive at a new job.  You are assigned a data conversion pulling data from system A and putting it into system B.

1.  You are unfamiliar with the business domain.
2.  You are given access to system A's database.  There is no dictionary and you can't access the front end of system A.  You've also never used the software.
3.  For the new system, your access is also limited.  You do have format's and explanations, more or less, some access to the front end of the system but it's almost useless because things often don't work.  You are also unfamiliar with this system.
4.  There is no discovery process and your access to the "business experts" is limited almost to the point of non-existence.
5.  The only tool you get to validate your data are some reports.  Roughly a 1/3 run.  The rest either error or are built against saved files that aren't current.

And the last gem, your boss has OCD, and flips out over any inaccurate data.

Besides failing, how do you get this done?  I'm particularly interested in how you would validate the data.  For example, this wasn't a sales project, but if you had to pull sales commissions from a system and weren't given access to the commission structure how could you make an educated best guess that you had it right?

I really did have to do something like this, it really was this awful and the manager actually kept a count of every pass I made.  I asked him how to verify the data, if he had any techniques, reports or ideas, his answer was "be more careful".  Okey dokey!

 
New Post 7/14/2017 4:05 AM
User is offline Kimbo
438 posts
5th Level Poster


Re: The Kobayashi Maru Data Project 

Hi

Looks like you've been set up to fail. Given what you've said, it will be virtually impossible to succeed as it stands.

 

Umm, what I'd do is insist on access to the data directly on both sides so you can map it. Are there people who can help you? Developers with access to tools? Do you know SQL or a database enquiry tool like SQL Server Manager, TOAD? can you run your own queries and work out the data structure somehow?

 

If you don't get access, think I'd write an email as a CYA exercise. Try escalating above the manager's head. He's your enemy anyway so no worries annoying him. If all else fails quit and move on.

 

Kimbo

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Data Analysis f...  The Kobayashi Maru Data Project

Community Blog - Latest Posts

Ekaterina Barabash
Ekaterina Barabash
I address my thoughts to those who are in IT management for whom the terms such as quality of project implementation development and profitability indicators of the company are important.  And it is also addressed to business analysts whose daily routine is the process of communication with Customer. A little about myself first. The last 8...
0 Responses
Dan Tasker
Dan Tasker
I have long been a believer in the saying “Context is everything.” As a business analyst dealing with business users, understanding the context of the topic of discussion is essential. In thinking about what constitutes quality requirements it occurred to me that there are a number of additional contexts that play a role. Examples inclu...
0 Responses
Alexey Kiselev
Alexey Kiselev
We are writing User Stories to fix the scope and describe - what our application should do when implemented.User Stories are great, because the are: Short, Defining Roles, A great connection of the requirement itself and a business need. User Story declared as a high level definition of the requirement, but it could be used to s...
0 Responses




Latest Articles

Demystifying Strategic Thinking in Business Analysis
Nov 12, 2018
2 Comments
One of my former business analysts on the team asked me this question recently; ‘I am really over being a BA. How do I move into strategy?&rsquo...
Featured Digital Library Resources 
Copyright 2006-2018 by Modern Analyst Media LLC